World News Trust World News Trust
World News Trust World News Trust
  • News Portal
  • All Content
    • Edited
      • News
      • Commentary
      • Analysis
      • Advisories
      • Source
    • Flatwire
  • Topics
    • Agriculture
    • Culture
      • Arts
      • Children
      • Education
      • Entertainment
      • Food and Hunger
      • Sports
    • Disasters
    • Economy
    • Energy
    • Environment
    • Government
    • Health
    • Media
    • Science
    • Spiritual
    • Technology
    • Transportation
    • War
  • Regions
    • Africa
    • Americas
      • North America
      • South America
    • Antarctica
    • Arctic
    • Asia
    • Australia/Oceania
    • Europe
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
      • Arctic Ocean
      • Atlantic Ocean
      • Indian Ocean
      • Pacific Ocean
      • Southern Ocean
    • Space
  • World Desk
    • Submit Content
  • About Us
  • Sign In/Out
  • Register
  • Site Map
  • Contact Us
  • The Techno-Feudal Method to Musk’s Twitter Madness | Yanis Varoufakis
  • Wars Aren’t Won with Peacetime Economies | Joseph E. Stiglitz
  • Strangers Behind the Trees: On the Death of Rayan Suliman and His Fear of Monsters | Ramzy Baroud
  • The Stagflationary Debt Crisis Is Here | Nouriel Roubini
  • How to Green Our Parched Farmlands & Finance Critical Infrastructure | Ellen Brown
  • From Great Moderation to Great Stagflation | Nouriel Roubini
  • The Road to Fascism: How the War in Ukraine is Changing Europe | Ramzy Baroud

PILLOW TALK: Artist Arrested For Selling Pillows | Deborah Goodwin

More items by author
Categories
Edited | Front Page Stories | Commentary -- WNT Original | North America | Business | Arts | Culture | Commentary | All Content
Tool Bar
View Comments

Mar. 7, 2012 (ShapeShiftas) -- A Friend I know, Diana, who makes beautiful hats, sent me an article with this startling headline: Artist Arrested For Selling Pillows.

It seems that artist Jemal McClary, who works as See One, made some pillowcovers in his signature painting style, and was selling them on the street in Soho, along with actual paintings-objects. He was arrested for not having a vendor's permit, even though he has been selling his artwork on the street for four years. Apparently, it's legal for artists to sell their creations on the street -- unless they are craft artists. You need a permit to sell crafts on the street.

So, See One's paintings, sewn into a pillow, made them Craft, not Art, at least in the eyes of the arresting officers. They added a disorderly conduct charge when he decided to argue aesthetics with them.

gridlock 

"Gridlock" - 2011 © See One

acrylic, spray paint and ink on canvas

fatigue-shards 

"Fatigue Shards" pillow by See One

limited-edition print with plush and pillow form

To me, See One's pillows are fabulous, and his graphic prints are perfect for fabric. (They would make awesome jersey wrap dresses, too.)  But, are they Art? This can be a very touchy subject for us Craftspeople and Designers. Just because we are making functional objects, are we no longer Artists? Are we any less creative because our pieces can be reproduced? Can pillows, plates, and garments be Art?

The law is no help here, from what I can determine. Artwork is protected by copyright laws, and See One owns all copyrights to his images, paintings, and prints -- but the pillow itself cannot be copyrighted. Same with garments, at least in the United States, you can't copyright the dress (you can copyright the pattern, but a seam shift here and a dart change there, and it's not your pattern anymore), but you can copyright the print it is made in.

That's basically how Louis Vuitton can protect their handbags from knock-offs; not because of the shape or construction of the bag, but because of the logo-print. (They are also protected by trademark laws, and I am not a lawyer, so don't quote me here!) I know there have been some recent efforts to address these gaps in copyright, or Intellectual Property, laws, but I can't imagine they (Congress) have passed anything helpful. I heard they busted a knock-off-handbag ring or two in New York, but you will still get accosted on the street in Chinatown to secretly buy Buittons or Hemres.

lvbag 

If they didn't cost so much, no one would want to knock them off! What about the 99%????!

OK, I can see how a factory-made handbag or teapot might not qualify as Art, no matter how beautiful, but what about handmade pieces that are beautiful and functional? Is it Art if it is made by one person, start to finish, but not when it is designed by one and made by others? Maybe if it is mostly beautiful and only a little functional, like vases, or wedding gowns? What about the amazing work of Dale Chihuly, that was certainly Art that I saw in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts last year (OMG! What a show!) But it's blown and formed glass, and he doesn't do any of the work himself...

chandelier 

These pieces are called "Chandeliers." Maybe a craftwork, if you have really high ceilings.

You can debate the art vs. craft issue ad nauseum. Some days, I consider myself an Artist, but most days I'm a designer, or a salesperson, or an artisan, sewing and stuffing my pillows. I like to say that I literally have my hands in the production of every ShapeShiftas' pillow. And even though each pillow is functional and reproduceable, I also think of my creations as artworks for the couch. To paraphrase Cab Calloway, Is I Is Or Is I Ain't An Artist? Since I want to be inclusive, not exclusive, and I think we can never have enough of Art, I guess I Is!

Just don't pour your cereal into those bowls, please.

peace, Deborah

Visit ShapeShiftas

 

QEUXQJGHS7GT


back to top
  • Created
    Sunday, March 11 2012
  • Last modified
    Wednesday, November 06 2013
  1. You are here:  
  2. Home
  3. All Content
  4. Edited
  5. PILLOW TALK: Artist Arrested For Selling Pillows | Deborah Goodwin
Copyright © 2023 World News Trust. All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU General Public License.