Civilizational Unity, Not Clash: How Gaza Challenged Samuel Huntington's Fantasies -- Ramzy Baroud
Ramzy Baroud -- World News Trust
May 9, 2024
Identity is fluid, because concepts such as culture, history and collective self-perceptions are never fixed. They are in a constant state of flux and revision.
For hundreds of years, the map of the Roman Empire seemed more Mediterranean and, ultimately, Middle Eastern than European -- per the geographic, or even geopolitical demarcation of today's Europe.
Hundreds of years of conflicts, wars and invasions redefined the Roman identity, splitting it by the end of the 4th century between West and East. But, even then, the political lines constantly changed, maps were repeatedly redrawn and identities fittingly redefined.
This applies to most of human history. True, war and conflict have served as drivers of change of maps - -and of our collective relationship with these maps -- but culture is also shaped and remodeled by other factors.
The permeation of the English language, for example, as a main tool of communication in the post-Cold War era, resulted in an invasion by U.S. and to a lesser extent, British entertainment - films, music, sports, etc. – of many parts of the world. This incursion has disrupted the natural cultural development of many societies, widening the generational gap and redefining social conceptions, values and priorities.
Such a sudden change in cultural flow is hardly conducive to the health of a nation, whose sense of self is the outcome of hundreds, if not thousands of years of social conflicts, struggles and, often, growth.
Thus, identity, as a permanent political signifier, cannot be trusted, since this vague concept is in a constant state of motion and because of the unprecedented connectivity among peoples all over the world. While such connectivity can lead to slow ethnocide, which is difficult to detect, let alone avoid, it can also help beleaguered, oppressed nations fight back.
Once upon a time, such self-serving theories as that of an impending "clash of civilizations" were all the rage among many U.S.-Western academics.
Samuel Huntington's division of the world into "major civilizations" whose relationships will be defined by conflict was a convenient addition to a history of such racist tropes, going as far as the early phases of Western colonialism.
Such thinking was propelled forward by political expediency, not rational thought, as it was marketed heavily following the collapse of the Soviet order, the first Iraq war and the emboldened Western militarism across Asia, the Middle East and the rest of the Global South.
Linking violent endeavors with such lofty words as civilizations -- some driven by universal values, while others, supposedly by extremism -- was a mere reintroduction of old mantras as Europe's "civilization mission" and the American "manifest destiny."
It all failed, anyway, or, more accurately, could not produce the desired outcome of keeping the world hostage to the West's definition of civilization, identities and human relations, thus the supposedly inevitable "clash."
Currently, there are signs of a new world emerging. It is not shaped by civilizational quests or impulses, but by the same old historical paradigm: those seeking power that can widen and protect their economic interests, and those fighting back, seeking freedom, justice, equality, rule of law and the like.
Those pursuing power can, and are uniting beyond their supposed civilization inclinations, religious values, racial orientations and geography.
Even before the Russia-Ukraine war, a new cold war was already emerging, between a declining empire, the United States, and a rising one, China.
Both Ukraine and Russia, according to Huntington, would serve as textbook examples of "Western civilization" versus the "Sinic civilization" -- lumped with others under the "Eastern world."
Yet, neither the refined approach of Barack Obama nor the populist style of Donald Trump succeeded in deepening this presumed civilizational clash. The rest of the world's relations with China continue to be governed by economic interests.
Even Washington's European allies, who rely heavily on Chinese trade and technological advancements, are not entirely persuaded in joining the trade war on Beijing in the name of common Western values and other such rhetoric.
As for those fighting back, the war on Gaza was an unexpected rallying cry for unity. Indeed, the war has resulted in a whole new formation of international relations that hardly existed prior to October 7.
Those speaking out for the Palestinians are not governed by religious, racial, geographic or even cultural boundaries. From Namibia to South Africa, from Brazil and Colombia to Nicaragua, and from China, to Russia to the Middle East, solidarity with Gaza is hardly defined from a narrow "civilization" perspective.
This includes the mass protests across the world, including throughout Europe and North America, where people from every color, race, age group, gender, religion and more are united in a single chant: ceasefire now.
Of course, there will always be those invested in dividing us around whatever lines may serve their political agendas which are almost always linked to economic interests and military might.
Yet, the global resistance to such delusional academics and chauvinistic politicians is stronger than ever before. Gaza has proven to be the ultimate unifier, as it has drawn a line that bonds all of Huntington’s civilizational groups, not around imminent conflict, but global justice.
- Dr. Ramzy Baroud is a journalist, author and the Editor of The Palestine Chronicle. He is the author of six books. His latest book, co-edited with Ilan Pappé, is ‘Our Vision for Liberation: Engaged Palestinian Leaders and Intellectuals Speak Out’. His other books include ‘My Father was a Freedom Fighter’ and ‘The Last Earth’. Baroud is a Non-resident Senior Research Fellow at the Center for Islam and Global Affairs (CIGA). His website is www.ramzybaroud.net
- CreatedThursday, May 09, 2024
- Last modifiedFriday, May 10, 2024
SUBSCRIBE
World Desk Activities
phys.org/news/2024-05-whales.html
Are we really about to talk to whales?
The past decade has seen an explosion of new research into some of the most fascinating sounds in the sea: the vocalizations of whales and…
phys.org/news/2024-05-black-teachers-lost-civil-ri…
How Black teachers lost when civil rights won in Brown v. Board
Brown v. Board of Education, the Supreme Court decision that desegregated public schools, stands in the collective national memory as a turning point in America's…
phys.org/news/2024-05-cancer-drug-pollution-global…
Cancer drug pollution is a growing global concern
As incidence of cancer increases globally, the use of cancer drugs is also growing at a rate of approximately 10 percent per year in developed…
phys.org/news/2024-05-summer-northern-hemisphere-h…
Summer 2023 was northern hemisphere's hottest for 2,000 years, tree rings show
The summer of 2023 was the warmest in the non-tropical areas of the northern hemisphere for 2,000 years, a new study has shown.
phys.org/news/2024-05-blooded-dinosaurs-roamed-ear…
When the first warm-blooded dinosaurs roamed Earth
Scientists once thought of dinosaurs as sluggish, cold-blooded creatures. Then research suggested that some could control their body temperature, but when and how that shift…
phys.org/news/2024-05-pyramids-built-lost-river-sc…
Pyramids built along long-lost river, scientists discover
Scientists have discovered a long-buried branch of the Nile river that once flowed alongside more than 30 pyramids in Egypt, potentially solving the mystery of…
phys.org/news/2024-05-danger-beauty-solar-storms.h…
'Danger behind the beauty': More solar storms could be heading our way
Tourists normally have to pay big money and brave cold climates for a chance to see an aurora, but last weekend many people around the…
techxplore.com/news/2024-05-terminal-diode-wireles…
A promising three-terminal diode for wireless communication and optically driven computing
Two-terminal devices are electronic components connected to electrical circuits via two electrical terminals. Although these components are the key building blocks of most existing devices,…
medicalxpress.com/news/2024-05-covid-vaccinations-…
Repeat COVID-19 vaccinations elicit antibodies that neutralize variants, other viruses
The COVID-19 pandemic is over, but the virus that caused it is still here, sending thousands of people to the hospital each week and spinning…
Latest Stories
Electronic Frontier Foundation
- Sunsetting Section 230 Will Hurt Internet Users, Not Big Tech May 20, 2024
- EFF to Court: Electronic Ankle Monitoring Is Bad. Sharing That Data Is Even Worse. May 17, 2024
- EFF Urges Ninth Circuit to Hold Montana’s TikTok Ban Unconstitutional May 17, 2024
- Fair Use Still Protects Histories and Documentaries—Even Tiger King May 15, 2024
The Intercept
VTDigger
- UVM halts plans to build housing near Centennial Woods May 20, 2024
- Brian Campion, Bennington state senator, won’t seek reelection May 20, 2024
- Rep. Larry Satcowitz: Gov. Phil Scott should sign the Flood Safety Act May 20, 2024
- Reps. Michael Marcotte, Stephanie Jerome and Monique Priestley: The Data Privacy Act balances Vermonters’ personal privacy with business operations May 20, 2024